Nonverbal
and Cross-cultural
Carol Kinsey Goman, Ph.D.
It was an important evening
for the civic leaders of a city in the Midwest. The local chamber
of commerce was hosting a dinner for executives from Japan who
were considering whether to locate a factory in that city. And
everything seemed to go wrong.
The cultural mishaps started
when the chamber president was formally introduced to the top
ranking Japanese executive. The president held out this hand for
a shake, the Japanese chairman bowed. The president then hastily
bowed, while his Japanese counterpart thrust out his hand. To
the embarrassment of all, this "gestural dance" continued
for several minutes,
Then things got worse .
. .
When everyone was finally
seated for dinner, the welcoming gifts for members of the Japanese
contingent were opened. They were lovely pocketknives, handsomely
engraved with the name of the Japanese company. Unfortunately,
the gift givers didn't realize that knives are a Japanese symbol
suggesting suicide.
By the end of the evening,
the city officials had managed to offend all their guests - without
saying a word.
In the high stakes world
of international business, nonverbal communication often speaks
for itself. Unfortunately, much of the meaning may be lost in
translation. The most innocuous of gestures - when its intent
is misinterpreted - can wreak havoc on business dealings.
Even the simplest hand
movement can get you into cross-cultural trouble.
Of course, it's okay to
talk with your hands - if you know what they're saying. Gestures
are powerful communicators in any culture and are obviously easier
to learn than language. Just be aware that some familiar hand
gestures can have very different meanings.
For example, in most European
countries, the correct way to wave hello and good-bye is palm
out, hand and arm stationary, fingers wagging up and down. Common
North American waving, with the hand moving side to side means
"no" throughout Mediterranean Europe and Latin America.
In Peru that gesture means "come here." Called the Moutza
in Greece, that same gesture is a serious insult, and the closer
the hand to the other person's face, the more threatening it is
considered to be.
The "thumbs up"
gesture that North Americans and many other cultures flash when
they want to signify "Good job!" or "Well done!"
is considered offensive in certain locales (Australia and Nigeria,
to mention just two) and should be avoided. In Germany, when you
order drinks, the gesture means "One, please."
When someone taps the side
of his nose with his forefinger, it signals a desire for confidentiality
or secrecy in many cultures. But, in the U.K., Holland, and Austria,
if the tap is to the front of the nose, it means "Mind your
own business."
Flashing the "V"
sign for victory in the United States suggests business negotiations
have concluded well. But that sentiment will be lost on anyone
from the U.K., Australia and New Zealand if the back of the hand
is facing out. In which case, it will be interpreted as a rude
gesture.
The crossed-fingers gesture
(the U.S. "Good luck!" signal -- or cancellation sign
when telling a lie) has several other meanings. In Turkey, the
gesture is used to break a friendship. Elsewhere it is used to
indicate that something is good or to swear an oath, or as a symbol
for copulation.
The eyelid pull, in which
the forefinger is placed on the cheekbone and pulled down to widen
the eye a little, translates to "I am alert" in France,
Germany, Yugoslavia and Turkey. In Spain and Italy it means "Be
alert." In Austria it signals boredom. In Saudi Arabia touching
the lower eyelid with the forefinger indicates stupidity.
Even the "Okay"
sign commonly used in the United States as signifying approval
is a gesture that has several different meanings according to
the country. In France it means zero; in Japan it is a symbol
for money; and in Brazil it carries a vulgar connotation.
Some hand gestures are
unique to a single culture. In Japan, people use a hand prow gesture
(the palm-edge of one hand is placed vertically forward in front
of the nose) accompanied by a slight bow to apologize for crossing
between two people or to move through a crowded room. The hand
acts like the prow of a ship cutting through water.
The greeting gesture that
most business people around the world use is the handshake, but
even that has its cultural nuances. In the U.S., the handshake
is most often effusive. We use several pumps of the arm, and a
strong grip to deliver an unspoken message of confidence. A Brit
may give three to five hand pumps, and in Germany or France, one
or two pumps is considered sufficient, with the pressure generally
lighter. In Asia, the grip is often rather limp. A light, lingering
handshake is generally more favored in Latin America, and to withdraw
the hand too quickly could be interpreted as an insult.
Some cultures add a cheek
kiss to the greeting. Scandinavians are happy with a single kiss,
the French prefer a double, and the Dutch, Belgians, and Arabs
go for a triple kiss. In Turkey, in addition to the normal handshake,
a much younger person may kiss your hand and press it to his head
as a sign of respect.
Exceptions to the handshake
greeting may be seen in Japan and South Korea (bowing), in India
(the namaste - palms held together in a prayer gesture) and in
Arabic and Islamic cultures (the salaam - touching the heart with
the right palm and then sweeping the forearm up and outward).
Professionals around the
world prefer to do business with people who put them at ease and
make them feel comfortable and appreciated. Cultural sensitivity
to nonverbal communication plays a large part in building that
kind of relationship. While you probably can't learn every hand
gesture used around the world, you can stay alert for and respectful
of the differences you observe. It's just good manners - and good
business!
Carol Kinsey Goman, Ph.D.,
is a coach, author and keynote speaker who addresses association,
government, and business audiences around the world. Her latest
book and program topic is THE NONVERBAL ADVANTAGE - Body Language
for Busy Professionals. For more information, contact Carol by
phone: 510-526-1727, email: CGoman@CKG.com, or through her website:
http://www.CKG.com.